Latin America Report
Wed June 4, 2014
Riding The Beast: A Migrant Crisis President Obama Calls Urgent
There’s a network of freight trains that runs the length of Mexico from its southernmost border with Guatemala north to the United States. In addition to grain, corn or scrap metal, these trains are carrying an increasing number of undocumented immigrants who aim to cross into the U.S.
And despite the many deadly challenges it poses, more and more children—both with adults and alone—have been risking the journey. That prompted President Obama this week to warn of "an urgent humanitarian situation."
These aren’t passenger trains; there are no panoramic windows, seats or even a roof to guard from sun or rain. People call the train La Bestia or The Beast. Some call it the Death Train.
It's estimated that up to half a million migrants now ride The Beast each year, sitting back-to-back along the spine of the cars, trying not to get knocked off their roof-top perch.
“They’re just packed,” says photojournalist Keith Dannemiller, who has lived in Mexico for the better part of three decades. “There’s not much room for anyone else to get on board by the time the train pulls out.”
For the International Organization for Migration, he recently documented the exploding number of migrants riding these trains--more and more of whom end up in South Florida these days.
Journeys on the train can take anywhere from a week to several months, and many migrants have made this trip more than once.
Lis-Marie Alvarado, who lives in Homestead, rode The Beast last year as part of an Al Jazeera America TV series called “Borderland.” She and five other Americans traced the journey of immigrants who died while making their way to America.
“It’s tiring being on top of there,” says Alvarado. “Not only with the sun, but also the water. There’s very limited water, and that's a constant, you know.”
Alvarado is herself an immigrant from Nicaragua and the only U.S. citizen in her family.
“People are taking the journey because you do want a better future, and you're willing to do whatever takes,” Alvarado says. “There are a lot of people who aren’t going to make it.”
Many Beast riders have suffered physical injury or death falling off the train or getting sucked into the wheels trying to board it in motion. In some areas, that's the only way on.
WHO TAKES THE JOURNEY
Most of those making this 1,450-mile trek are not from Mexico. They come from Central American countries like Guatemala, El Salvador and Honduras, which has the world's highest murder rate.
One of the things that struck Dannemiller while documenting the Beast was just how many kids were riding the train.
Instead of merry-go-round horses, kids from these countries are hoisted onto the back of this metal beast that’s just as likely to spit them out as it is to shepherd them safely to the border.
In 2011, U.S. border patrol detained around 6,800 undocumented children. In 2012, that rose to 13,000; last year it was 24,000. Most estimates predict more than 60,000 minors will be detained this year alone.
“A lot of the people are not fleeing because of economic hardship,” says Dannemiller. “A lot of them are fleeing because the increase in the drug violence and threats, extortion, and that's a different phenomenon. Before, you could call these people migrants with no problem. I think now, the term refugee might be a little bit more apropos for who these people are and what they’re going through.”
CAUSE OF THE INFLUX
Some attribute this crisis, the reason people are willing to risk their lives on a train like The Beast to the United States. Genevieve Wood articulated this in her most recent installment on The Daily Signal, an online publication from the Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank.
“The fact that the United States is having a debate over immigration," says Wood, "and [because] it appears to many people that amnesty will be a part of any immigration reform, many people believe, ‘If we can just get into the country, if we can get there and live there illegally, eventually we’re going to be given legal status.’”
She believes it is that illusion--sometimes fatal--that drives people to make this journey to the U.S.
Wood says current immigration policy is “encouraging people to put their children at risk.”
Alvarado rejects this idea. She believes those making the journey, even the kids, don’t wear rose-colored glasses as they board the train. They know the dangers, the odds and the possibility of being deported later, even if they make it across the border.
“The fact [is], people are willing to die to escape something that's terrible.”
You can read more of WLRN's Latin America coverage here.
"Borderland" can be seen on the Al Jazeera America channel.
Latin America Report
Latin America Report