Ending Rape on Campus a Matter of Consent

Dec 14, 2015

There's a disturbing reality about college life today. Roughly one in four students, predominantly women, will become victims of some form of sexual assault, according to a new survey.

That's according to the Association of American Universities (AAU).  It  recently released a  survey of 150,000 students from 27 universities. What the survey shows is that about 23 percent reported an incident of sexual assault including sexual misconduct due to physical force, threats of physical force or incapacitation. A little more than 10 percent said they experienced sexual assault due to penetration.

There were 456 pinwheels planted along one of the walkways in the central part of the University of Miami campus. Teal is the color that represents sexual assault awareness. These represent the number of students who will be sexually assaulted at UM, according to the AAU survey.
Credit Luis Hernandez / WLRN

These figures don't usually match what one might see on a university's crime statistics. As an example, the University of Miami crime statistics (p.23) show that on average there are about four to five sexual assault cases reported on campus annually. There are another four in student residences reported at the same time. 

If the AAU statistics are right, then there would be many more.  To demonstrate this, a campus group planted pinwheels along one of the walkways in the center of campus. There were more than 450, and they represent each man and woman expected to be a victim of sexual assault based on those statistics.

The greatest challenge for advocates battling the problem across the nation's university campuses is simply reporting. People don't want to come forward and admit what has happened.

The AAU survey shows that reporting of incidents is low, between 5 and 28 percent depending on the severity of the crime. 

Tony Lake is UM's the associate dean of students and the director of judicial affairs. He agrees that there are more assaults than are reported.

"It's a lot worse than schools want to point  to, absolutely. No school wants to admit that there's an issue on their campus."

But he points out one reason why those figures don't match.

"Statistics are tricky, because what gets reported are instances that come through, not the final resolution of those cases. The requirement is violation of the law. If something is just reported to us and not the U.M.P.D. [university police] we have to work it out with them to see if the incident, as it was described to us, is also a violation of the law."

Dean Lake believes the numbers will begin climbing as more students start coming forward and reporting their assaults. And it is starting to happen at schools across the U.S. In a report by the Washington Post, many universities are already showing increases in the number of sexual assaults on campus. They found that reports of sexual assault on campuses were up 50 percent in a three-year period between 2009 and 2012.

Patricia Ireland graduated from UM in 1975. She returned at Canes Consent to share her knowledge with the students now trying to make a difference.
Credit Luis Hernandez / WLRN

Not everyone thinks universities are reporting enough. Patricia Ireland is one of them.  Ireland, the former president of the National Organization for Women, is a 1975 UM graduate. She believes universities are afraid to step forward on this issue.

"Universities are concerned with their image and with lawsuits. They're also worried that the federal funding is going to be at risk because there's been a change in Title IX."

Ireland is talking about the fact that the U.S. Department of Education is now going after institutions of higher education for not following the law created to rid schools of discrimination. There are specific rules within the law that are focused on how university officials must deal with cases of sexual harassment and sexual assault.   This was made clear in 2011 in a "dear colleague" letter. Last year the DOE also released a list of 55 schools under investigation for their handling of sexual assault complaints. The only Florida school on the list was Florida State University.

The other part of Ireland's comment, that universities are facing lawsuits,  is also happening in some cases. Kevin Parisi is a student at Drew University in New Jersey who  filed a lawsuit against the school alleging that the university hurt his academic career, although he had not been found responsible for an alleged assault.

One of the underlying themes of Canes Consent is the idea of consent, the idea that respecting the consent of another ends rape.
Credit Luis Hernandez / WLRN

Canes Consent is the brainchild of Dr. Katherine Westaway. She started the program three years ago and now guides her students to organize events each semester. This term, it was the students of her newly created Sex and Sexuality class who put the event together.

The event and the class are her attempts at changing attitudes about sex, which she believes will end sexual assault.

"We still have a huge problem talking honestly about sex. What happens with that is we do not talk about affirmative consent. Then, when people get raped, they think it's their fault."

Dr. Westaway has her own personal history with the topic, being a victim herself many years ago in school. At the end of each Canes Consent, victims, whether they have identified themselves or not, step up and stand together to bring attention to their stories. It's also a sort of jab at the university in some cases. There have been young women who have spoken out against the university's handling of their cases, claiming that their assailant wasn't punished or wasn't kept a safe distance from the accuser.

Dr. Katherine Westaway leads her students in one final moment of solidarity against sexual assault on campus at the end of Canes Consent.
Credit Luis Hernandez / WLRN

Victims come forward during Canes Consent to share their stories. Some don't give their name because they fear their attacker may retaliate, especially if they're still on campus.

Dr. Westaway believes this is important in the mission, to hear from those who have been victimized. 

"I think it's the best revelation of what the experience is really like and I think this is the best way to change people's hearts and minds. When you hear one or two rape stories, you're not going to think about it the same."

Last year President Barack Obama announced the national campaign "It's On Us" as an effort to curb the rise of sexual assaults on campus. They released a series of recommendations on how universities and colleges can reduce sexual assault and rape on campus. They include:

  • Creation of systematic surveys to help schools learn what's happening on their campus. 
  • Creating bystander intervention, or encouraging witnesses to step forward.
  • Identifying trained victim advocates who can provide emergency support.

The university provides services to students who are victims of sexual assault. They include the Sexual Assault Resource Team (S.A.R.T.). There's also on-campus counseling. And, there's the Rape Treatment Center at Jackson Memorial Hospital. (3o5-585-5185).